hard to say not know what's broken....
but personally I'd probably go back with the same batwing thing, especially if the base part was still good. I figure they are good enough and the fact that they crank up higher than those shorter fixed height ones might make for an almost negligible improvement...and probably a bit cheaper.
but if the whole thing is wrecked and I'd need to take it all the way down to a hole in the roof I'd probably go with one of those circular UFO looking omnidirection things that does not crank up and down.... Not as good for distant stations as a directional model like the king Jack, but we don't watch much over the air so it wouldn't matter much.
__________________
|