We upgraded from a Forest River Wolf Pup 16BHS to a Shadow Cruiser 225RBS. I can't tell you much in comparison to the other models that you mentioned.
I will say that compared to the Wolf Pup, the SC is a light years improvement, but still an RV. I purchased a month ago and already having issues with the front lock and some graphics delamination and some interior touches, but a lot of that is exacerbated by nearly two weeks of solid rain here in Oklahoma.
On the other hand, it's the other touches that I love. Much more interior storage than the Wolf Pup, including a silverware drawer (it's little things like that). I can close the bathroom door and still use the toilet, which was impossible in the Wolf Pup.
__________________
|